d3ro-voice/apps/desktop/tests/eval/analysis/hybrid_eval.py

78 lines
3.1 KiB
Python

"""Hybrid: LLM first word vs personal n-gram guess on identical cases.
Reports exact first-word hits and 'useful' hits (guess is a prefix of the true first word: Korean stem + ending).
"""
import json
import re
import sqlite3
import sys
from collections import Counter, defaultdict
db_path, cases_path, out_path = sys.argv[1], sys.argv[2], sys.argv[3]
db = sqlite3.connect('file:' + db_path + '?mode=ro', uri=True)
texts = [r[0] for r in db.execute("select text from typing_samples where source in ('typed','voice')")]
texts += [r[0] for r in db.execute(
"select coalesce(polished_text, original_text) from history where coalesce(polished_text, original_text) is not null")]
cases = json.load(open(cases_path, encoding='utf-8'))
out = open(out_path, 'w', encoding='utf-8')
TRAIL = re.compile(r'[\s.!?。!?…~,"\')]+$')
def words(text):
return [TRAIL.sub('', w) for w in re.sub(r'\s+', ' ', text or '').strip().split(' ') if w]
def ngram_guess(prefix_words, exclude):
bi, tri = defaultdict(Counter), defaultdict(Counter)
for text in texts:
if exclude in re.sub(r'\s+', ' ', text):
continue
ws = words(text)
for i in range(1, len(ws)):
bi[ws[i - 1]][ws[i]] += 1
if i >= 2:
tri[(ws[i - 2], ws[i - 1])][ws[i]] += 1
if len(prefix_words) >= 2 and tri.get((prefix_words[-2], prefix_words[-1])):
word, n = tri[(prefix_words[-2], prefix_words[-1])].most_common(1)[0]
return word, n, 'tri'
if prefix_words and bi.get(prefix_words[-1]):
word, n = bi[prefix_words[-1]].most_common(1)[0]
return word, n, 'bi'
return None, 0, None
stats = Counter()
for c in cases:
truth = words(c['truth'])
if not truth:
continue
t0 = truth[0]
full = re.sub(r'\s+', ' ', c['prefix'] + c['truth']).strip()
g, n, kind = ngram_guess(words(c['prefix']), full)
llm = words(c['suggestion'])
l0 = llm[0] if llm else None
stats['cases'] += 1
for name, guess in (('llm', l0), ('ngram', g)):
if guess:
stats[f'{name}_shown'] += 1
stats[f'{name}_exact'] += guess == t0
stats[f'{name}_useful'] += len(guess) >= 1 and t0.startswith(guess)
if g and l0:
stats['both'] += 1
if g == l0 or l0.startswith(g):
stats['agree'] += 1
stats['agree_exact'] += g == t0
stats['agree_useful'] += t0.startswith(g)
# hybrid policy: ngram when it has a guess, otherwise LLM
h = g or l0
if h:
stats['hyb_shown'] += 1
stats['hyb_useful'] += t0.startswith(h)
stats['hyb_exact'] += h == t0
N = stats['cases']
p = lambda k, d: f"{stats[k]}/{stats[d]} = {stats[k]/stats[d]:.3f}" if stats[d] else '-'
print(f'cases {N}', file=out)
for name in ('llm', 'ngram', 'hyb'):
print(f"{name:6} shown {stats[name + '_shown']/N:.3f} exact|shown {p(name + '_exact', name + '_shown')} useful|shown {p(name + '_useful', name + '_shown')}", file=out)
print(f"agree (ngram==LLM first word) {p('agree', 'both')} exact {p('agree_exact', 'agree')} useful {p('agree_useful', 'agree')}", file=out)